News, Reviews & Overviews

Who Is the Worst Brawler in Brawl Stars?

Yo, Brawl Stars fam! In the wild, ever-changing arena of Brawl Stars, where balance patches and new brawlers can flip the meta faster than a Mortis dash, one question keeps players buzzing: who is the worst brawler in Brawl Stars? As of July 2025, the data points to Barley as the weakest link, rocking a dismal 21.9% win rate and a measly 0.16% pick rate, landing him in the F-tier. But is Barley truly the worst brawler in Brawl Stars, or can this bottle-throwing bartender still hold his own in the right hands? This guide dives deep into Barley’s struggles, the 2025 meta, detailed stats, community takes, and strategies to either make him work or shut him down. Plus, we’ll show how LFCarry’s Brawl Stars boosting service can help you climb ranks, even with the underdogs. Let’s get into it!

Table of Contents

The 2025 Meta: Why Barley’s Falling Behind

The Brawl Stars meta in July 2025 is all about speed, burst damage, and versatility. Top-tier brawlers like Mortis, Mandy, Piper, Bea, Fang, Colt, Draco, Rico, Angelo, and Chuck dominate, thanks to their high mobility, strong Supers, and ability to shine across modes like Knockout, Wipeout, and Brawl Ball. These brawlers thrive in the fast-paced, open-map-heavy meta, where quick repositioning and high-damage output are king.

Barley, a Rare brawler with an area-denial kit, doesn’t fit this vibe. His main attack lobs bottles that create puddles dealing ~1,120 damage per second, but enemies can easily dodge them. His Super throws five fiery bottles for wider coverage, but it lacks the burst to secure kills. With only 4,800 HP at level 11 and normal movement speed, Barley’s a sitting duck against assassins like Kit or tanks like Frank. His gadgets—Sticky Syrup Mixer (slows enemies) and Herbal Tonic (heals allies)—don’t provide enough utility to compete with meta picks.

Key Weaknesses of Barley

  • Low Health Pool: At 4,800 HP, Barley gets melted by burst-damage brawlers like Fang or Draco.
  • Normal Movement Speed: He can’t reposition or escape fast attackers, unlike meta brawlers with high mobility.
  • Weak Star Power: “Extra Noxious” only boosts DPS by 13% (+200 damage per second), while “Medical Use” (heals 480 HP per attack) is preferred but still underwhelming.
  • Easily Countered: Brawlers like Jessie, Amber, 8-Bit, Bea, and Pam counter his area-denial with stronger kits or direct damage.
  • Map Dependency: Barley shines on maps with chokepoints (e.g., Snake Prairie) but flops on open maps like Backyard Bowl.

Statistical Breakdown: Barley’s Performance in July 2025

The numbers paint a rough picture for Barley. Barley’s 21.9% win rate and 0.16% pick rate in July 2025 make him the lowest-performing brawler among the top 200 players. This win rate means he wins only about 22 out of 100 matches, far below the average brawler. His pick rate shows even skilled players avoid him, likely due to his lack of versatility. Here’s how he performs across key modes:

Game Mode

Rank

Star Player %

Notes

Brawl Ball

39/93

0.79%

Decent for area control

Solo Showdown

77/93

0.12%

Struggles against mobile brawlers

Trio Showdown

54/93

0.46%

Limited impact

Knockout

52/93

0.24%

Poor in open maps

Brawl Hockey 2v2

90/93

0.02%

Nearly unplayable

Brawl Ball 2v2

72/93

0.17%

Weak performance

Duo Showdown

73/93

0.27%

Low viability

Comparing Barley to Other Low-Tier Brawlers

Other F-tier brawlers like Pam (25% win rate), Edgar (23.5%), and Moe (~24%) also struggle but fare slightly better. Pam’s healing turret makes her a niche support in Heist, while Edgar’s short-range burst works in low-trophy Solo Showdown. Moe’s low damage limits him, but he’s more versatile in team comps. Barley’s unique area-denial kit sets him apart, but it’s not enough to compete in the current meta, per Brawl Time Ninja.

Why Barley Struggles in the Current Meta

Barley’s kit hasn’t kept up with the 2025 meta’s demands. Here’s a deeper look at his weaknesses:

  • Low Damage Output: His bottles deal ~1,120 damage per second, but enemies can step out of puddles, reducing his effectiveness. Compared to brawlers like Surge, who deal instant burst damage, Barley’s DoT (damage over time) is too slow.
  • Fragile Survivability: With 4,800 HP, he’s vulnerable to assassins like Kit or Cordelius, who can close the gap and burst him down.
  • Map Dependency: Open maps like New Horizons or Knockout Grounds expose his weaknesses, as enemies can dodge his attacks easily. He’s only viable on maps with tight spaces.
  • Outclassed by Counters: Brawlers like Jessie (stronger turret), Amber (faster area control), and Bea (long-range precision) outshine him in similar roles.
  • Weak Gadgets and Star Powers: “Sticky Syrup Mixer” is useful for escapes but lacks offensive power, while “Herbal Tonic” is situational. “Extra Noxious” adds minimal DPS, making “Medical Use” the better choice for sustain.

The meta’s shift toward Hypercharge-heavy brawlers, like Surge’s range-boosting upgrade, has further sidelined Barley.

Strategies for Playing or Countering Barley

Despite his F-tier status, Barley can still be a menace in the right setup. Here’s how to play him or take him down:

Playing Barley Effectively

  • Map Selection: Stick to maps with chokepoints, like Snake Prairie, Cavern Churn, or Gem Fort, where puddles can block paths. Avoid open maps like Backyard Bowl.
  • Build Optimization: Use “Medical Use” Star Power for sustain (480 HP per attack) and “Sticky Syrup Mixer” Gadget to slow enemies at objectives. Shield Gear adds 900 HP for survivability, per BrawlHub.co.
  • Team Synergy: Pair with tanks like Frank or El Primo to soak damage or healers like Poco to keep him alive. In Brawl Ball, use puddles to block goal paths.
  • Positioning: Stay behind walls to lob bottles safely. Focus on controlling objectives like the Gem mine, Hot Zone areas, or Heist safes.
  • Mode-Specific Tips:
    • Hot Zone: Use puddles to lock down zones, forcing enemies to retreat or take damage.
    • Duo Showdown: Control key areas to secure kills or push enemies into traps.
    • Heist: Slow enemies approaching the safe with puddles, giving your team time to defend.

Countering Barley

  • Mobile Brawlers: Cordelius, Kit, or Leon can dodge puddles and close in for quick kills.
  • Tanks: Bull or El Primo can absorb his damage and overwhelm him with close-range power.
  • Snipers: Piper or Angelo can pick him off from outside his range, rendering his bottles useless.
  • Map Awareness: Stay mobile to avoid puddles and flank him using map cover.

If you’re struggling to win with Barley or want to climb ranks faster, LFCarry’s Brawl Stars carry service can pair you with pros to boost your trophies or teach you how to maximize even the weakest brawlers.



Historical Performance of Barley

Barley’s journey in Brawl Stars has seen ups and downs. In earlier seasons, he was a solid pick for area control in modes like Heist and Siege, thanks to his ability to lock down objectives. However, as the game evolved with new brawlers, Hypercharges, and map changes, Barley’s viability tanked. By July 2025, his performance had hit an all-time low, with Brawl Time Ninja showing him as the least effective brawler across most modes. Balance changes favoring burst damage and mobility have left his slow, DoT-based kit in the dust.

Past vs. Present

  • 2017–2020: Barley was a mid-tier pick, valued for his area control in closed maps.
  • 2021–2023: New brawlers and gadgets outclassed him, but he remained viable in niche scenarios.
  • 2024–2025: Hypercharges and open-map dominance pushed him to F-tier, with his win rate dropping to 21.9%.

Potential Buffs for Barley

Could Barley make a comeback? Supercell has a history of rebalancing underperforming brawlers, like Rosa’s shift from overpowered to balanced. Potential buffs could include:

  • Health Boost: Increasing his HP to ~5,500 would make him more durable.
  • Movement Speed: A slight speed increase could help him reposition or escape.
  • Damage Buff: Raising his bottle damage to ~1,400 per second would make his puddles more threatening.
  • Super Enhancement: Extending his Super’s duration or adding a slow effect could improve its impact.
  • Gadget Rework: Making “Herbal Tonic” heal more or “Sticky Syrup Mixer” last longer could add utility.

Players should keep an eye on patch notes for updates, as a buff could shift Barley’s viability, per Supercell’s Release Notes.

Best Maps and Modes for Barley

While Barley struggles overall, he can shine in specific scenarios where his area-denial kit excels:

  • Hot Zone: His puddles can lock down zones, forcing enemies to take damage or retreat. Maps like Ring of Fire or Dueling Beetles are ideal.
  • Duo Showdown: Control key areas to secure kills or push enemies into traps. Maps like Cavern Churn work well.
  • Heist: Slow enemies approaching the safe with puddles, giving your team time to defend. Try maps like Safe Zone.
  • Brawl Ball: Block goal paths with puddles on maps like Sneaky Fields or Pinball Dreams.

Pro Tips for Barley

  • Puddle Placement: Aim for high-traffic areas like Gem spawns or Hot Zone points to maximize damage.
  • Gadget Timing: Use “Sticky Syrup Mixer” to trap enemies in chokepoints or escape melee brawlers.
  • Team Comps: Pair with tanks (Frank, El Primo) or healers (Poco, Byron) to compensate for low health.
  • Practice in Duels: Barley’s slightly higher win rate in Duels makes it a good mode to hone your skills.

Community Insights and Debates

The Brawl Stars community is vocal about Barley’s struggles. On Reddit, players like u/DieselQ9 call him “legit bad” due to his weak damage and vulnerability, while u/Quaxlyboi argues he can shine in Brawl Ball with smart puddle placement. Some players, like u/Skeleton_Gangster_TV, note that Barley’s area control can still be effective in low-trophy matches (<700 trophies), per BrawlHub.co. However, competitive data from Noff.gg confirms his F-tier status among top players, highlighting a divide between casual and competitive play.

Interestingly, some sources place Barley in B-tier, noting he’s “really bad” but playable at low trophies. This discrepancy reflects different evaluation methods: data-driven lists (Noff.gg) focus on top-tier performance, while community-driven lists (BrawlHub.co) consider broader player experiences. Regardless, Barley’s low win rate and pick rate cement his status as a bottom-tier pick in July 2025.

Community Quotes

  • u/HellSlayer69: “Barley’s puddles are a joke against anyone who knows how to move. Needs a buff ASAP.”
  • u/BrawlMaster_X: “I’ve had success with Barley in the Hot Zone with a tank teammate, but he’s useless in Knockout.”

Comparing Barley to Other Low-Tier Brawlers

Barley’s not alone in the struggle bus. Other F-tier brawlers include:

  • Pam: Her healing turret and tanky kit are outshined by stronger supports like Gene. She’s slightly more viable in Heist but lacks impact.
  • Edgar: His short-range attacks and jump Super are predictable, making him easy to counter at high levels, though he’s decent in low-trophy Solo Showdown.
  • Moe: Low damage and a slow Super charge rate limit him, but he’s more versatile in team comps than Barley.
  • Willow: Her control-based kit struggles against mobile brawlers, but she’s slightly better in specific scenarios.

Barley’s unique area-denial kit sets him apart, but his weaknesses make him less viable than these peers in competitive play.

Future Prospects for Barley

Could Barley make a comeback? Supercell has a track record of rebalancing underperforming brawlers, like Rosa’s shift from overpowered to balanced. A buff to Barley’s health, damage, or gadgets could bring him back into the meta. For example, increasing his HP to ~5,500 or boosting his bottle damage to ~1,400 per second could make him more competitive. Players should monitor patch notes for updates, as a meta shift or new map designs could also favor his playstyle. Until then, he remains a niche pick for dedicated players.

FAQs

Is Barley really the worst brawler in Brawl Stars?

Data from Noff.gg shows Barley with a 21.9% win rate, the lowest in July 2025, making him the weakest in competitive play. However, he can be effective in niche modes like Hot Zone or Brawl Ball with the right strategy.

How can I improve with Barley?

Focus on maps with chokepoints, use “Sticky Syrup Mixer” to control objectives, and pair with tanks or healers. Practice positioning to lob bottles safely and maximize area denial.

Will Barley get buffed in future updates?

While it’s uncertain, his low performance suggests Supercell might consider buffs to his health, damage, or gadgets. Check patch notes for updates.

Which modes are best for Barley?

Hot Zone, Duo Showdown, Heist, and Brawl Ball are his strongest modes due to their reliance on area control.

What brawlers counter Barley effectively?

Mobile brawlers (Cordelius, Kit, Leon), tanks (Bull, El Primo), and snipers (Piper, Angelo) counter Barley by dodging his puddles or outranging him.

 

Why Choose This Service from Us at LFCarry?

At LFCarry, we know the Brawl Stars grind can be brutal, especially with brawlers like Barley dragging you down. Our professional boosting services are built to help you dominate, whether you’re pushing trophies or mastering tough matchups. With our Brawl Stars boosting service, you get:

  • Unique Value: Our pros know every brawler’s strengths and weaknesses, helping you maximize even F-tier picks like Barley.
  • Benefit to Gamers: Skip the grind and hit your target rank fast, saving you hours of frustration.
  • Trust / Safety: Your account is secure with our trusted, ban-proof methods.
  • Speed / Results: We deliver rapid progress, getting you to the top in no time.

Don’t let Barley’s low win rate hold you back. Join LFCarry and brawl your way to victory!

Back to blog
Get Your Boost

Read also:

Leave a Reply

  • Written by: Darya Chavez
  • Posted on: August 4, 2025